The Feeding "Mistake" That I Consider Unethical...

Story at-a-glance -

  • Dogs must eat animal protein because, of the 22 essential amino acids they need to meet their metabolic and energy requirements, they make only 12. The other 10 must be sourced from the diet as preformed amino acids
  • Cats are obligate carnivores, meaning they must eat meat to survive. Cats have virtually no capacity to turn plant proteins into the missing pieces needed for a complete amino acid profile
  • The nutritional deficiencies and imbalances that result from a vegetarian or vegan pet diet inevitably lead to serious and sometimes irreversible medical conditions down the road
  • The vast majority of both conventional and holistic veterinarians are against feeding carnivorous dogs and cats vegetarian or vegan diets, and recent research also shows many of these diets are nutritionally deficient
  • Forcing one’s personal lifestyle of vegetarianism or veganism on a species designed to eat a meat-based diet is unethical

By Dr. Becker

Last week in part 1 of my 2-part video series on why vegan and vegetarian diets are a bad idea for meat-eating pets, I discussed the carnivorous nature of dogs and cats, and how their bodies are very expertly designed to thrive on a diet of animal protein.

This week I want to talk about exactly why animal protein is so crucial to the health of cats and dogs, and why it is unethical to force them to eat a plant-based diet.

Why Dogs Need Animal Protein

Dogs require 22 essential amino acids to handle all their metabolic and energy needs, but their bodies only produce 12 of the 22. The other 10 must come from the food they eat. Because the canine digestive tract is short and simple, it doesn't produce the enormous amounts of amino acids that herbivores do, which is why your dog must obtain preformed amino acids directly from his diet.

The protein you feed your dog should provide a wide spectrum of amino acids to meet his nutritional needs. The protein sources with wide-spectrum amino acid profiles include beef, bison, chicken, eggs, fish, lamb, rabbit, turkey, goat, venison, and elk.

Protein is a crucial component of every cell in your pet's body. Essential amino acids from high-quality animal protein build healthy cells, organs, and muscles, and provide necessary enzymes and hormones as well.

The fat in your dog's diet aids in the absorption of certain vitamins, and provides energy and essential fatty acids. Fatty acids from animal sources are important for healing, normal cell membrane synthesis, reproduction, and a healthy coat and skin.

Why Cats Need Animal Protein

As I mentioned earlier, cats are obligate carnivores. Obligate means "by necessity" or "by biologic requirement." In other words, cats must eat meat to survive. The protein in animal tissue has a complete amino acid profile.

Plant proteins do not contain all the amino acids critical for the health of obligate carnivores. Kitties have zero capacity to turn plant proteins into the missing pieces needed for a complete amino acid profile.

One of the amino acids missing in plants is taurine, which is found in animal muscle meat, and in particular, the tissues of the heart and liver. Taurine deficiency causes serious health problems in cats, including cardiovascular disease and blindness.

Additional Considerations: Vitamin D, Essential Fatty Acids, and Protein Quality

Neither cats nor dogs make vitamin D in their skin from sunlight, so it also needs to come from their diet. The vitamin D needs to be vitamin D3 (which comes from animal sources), not vitamin D2 (which comes from plant-based sources). Dogs can use D2 to some extent, but cats cannot – they must have D3 in their diet.

Unlike humans, dogs and cats lack the enzymes necessary to convert vegetable sources of omega-3 essential fatty acids like alpha-linolenic acid (ALA) into adequate amounts of docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) and eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA).

Dogs and cats on a vegetarian diet are deficient in both DHA and EPA, which leads to a number of inflammatory and degenerative issues down the line.

The quality of protein you feed your dog or cat is also very important. We know that high-quality flesh meats are easier for pets to digest, absorb, and use properly. I strongly advise people to avoid non-meat sources of protein for carnivores, including soy and corn, as not only are they not species appropriate, they're also frequently genetically modified and treated with pesticides.

I strongly believe that fat and protein in the diets of pet carnivores should come from ethically raised, whole food sources. In vegetarian and vegan diets for pets, the amino acids, vitamins, and minerals must be supplemented from synthetic sources, which in my opinion is not ideal, because it's not whole food.

In summary, the risks of feeding dogs and cats a vegetarian or vegan diet include:

  • Inadequate total protein intake1
  • Imbalances of certain amino acids such as taurine and l-carnitine
  • Imbalances in essential fatty acids, in particular arachidonic acid for cats
  • A deficiency in vitamins and minerals – such as the B vitamins, calcium, phosphorous, and iron – will also occur as these nutrients are obtained ideally or only through meat, bone and other animal products

These nutritional deficiencies and imbalances can ultimately lead to serious and sometimes irreversible medical conditions.

Veterinary Community Is United in Refusing to Support Vegetarian or Vegan Diets for Dogs and Cats

Occasionally, veterinarians will prescribe a vegan diet for a temporary allergy elimination dietary trial. Although this is never my approach, if it goes on for just a month or two, it shouldn't cause significant or permanent damage to an adult animal.

If your vet is suspicious that your pet is sensitive to a particular type of protein, I suggest you consider completing Dr. Dodds' NutriScan saliva test. The test results will highlight the foods your pet should avoid.

Other than when attempting to identify food allergies, the vast majority of conventional and holistic veterinarians do not advocate or support feeding carnivores as vegetarians. I made this video because passionate vegetarians and vegans oftentimes feel otherwise and really want their carnivorous companion animals to become vegan or vegetarian.

I regularly get calls from potential new clients that hear I'm a vegetarian veterinarian and believe I will be supportive of their desire to transition their dog or cat to a vegetarian diet. They are sad to learn I don't encourage this.

Many veterinarians, including me, have clients that say, "Well, I've been feeding my dog as a vegan for two years and she appears to be doing great." A few years down the road, we're treating these unfortunate animals for preventable degenerative diseases, including Type 2 diabetes from too many carbohydrates, heart failure from lack of amino acids, and serious musculoskeletal problems from trace mineral nutritional deficiencies.

Bottom Line: Please Don't Put Your Personal Beliefs Ahead of the Health of Your Pet

Pet owners who force their carnivorous companion animals to eat meat-free diets are placing their personal beliefs in a vegetarian or vegan lifestyle ahead of their pet's physiologic requirement for a meat-based diet.

My vegan friend, Megan, doesn't like it when I use the term "force" to describe what pet guardians do when they choose to feed a dog or cat a non-meat based diet.

So I made a simple suggestion to Megan. I suggested she offer her dog two options – a fresh, species-appropriate, and ethically raised meat-based diet, and a fresh vegan-based diet… and then watch which one the dog eats. Needless to say, the dog picked the meat-based meal, which perfectly proves the point that to feed a carnivore a diet he wouldn't choose for himself is indeed forcing him to survive on a diet his body was not designed to process or thrive on.

In conclusion, this is really just about using common sense and keeping the best interests of your pet as your number one priority. If your personal eating habits or philosophy are so strong that everyone in your family must abide by them, I encourage you to pick a species to care for whose God-given dietary needs are aligned with yours. If you're a committed vegetarian or vegan and can't stand the sight or even the thought of meat, choose a companion animal designed by nature as a vegetarian.

If your pet happens to be a rabbit and you're all about the Paleo lifestyle, please don't force your carnivorous habits onto your bunny. If your pet is a snake, don't be angry when he turns down salad. You get the idea…

Pushing your personal nutritional philosophy on another species that doesn't have the same biologic requirements as you do isn't ethical.